Heat exhaustion vs heat stroke: two runners on a dry canyon trail under strong sun

Heat Exhaustion vs Heat Stroke, and the One Sign That Tells Them Apart

Heat exhaustion vs heat stroke comes down to one question you can answer on the trail: is this person still acting like themselves?

From a few meters away the two can look the same. Pale or flushed, soaked in sweat, breathing hard, moving badly. One needs shade, fluids and an hour of rest. The other means the body’s cooling has failed and core temperature is climbing past 40°C (104°F), and how fast you cool them in the next few minutes shapes how this ends.

Awareness, not medical advice

This article is here so you recognize the situation, not so you manage it alone. When in doubt, treat it as heat stroke and call for help.

It doesn’t take a heatwave

Heat illness on trek is built from exertion as much as air temperature. A loaded pack raises your work rate and covers most of your back, so the sweat there can’t evaporate and cool you. Above the tree line there can be hours without shade. Humidity slows evaporation further. A steep climb with a heavy pack on a humid 24°C (75°F) day produces plenty of heat, and your body can fall behind without the thermometer looking alarming.

Fitness brings its own trap. A fit, motivated hiker can override the early warnings and keep climbing, and that’s how a manageable problem turns into a dangerous one.

Heat exhaustion: still themselves

Heat exhaustion is the body working flat out to shed heat and starting to lose ground. Expect heavy sweating, weakness or wobbly legs, headache, nausea, dizziness and thirst, with skin that’s often cool and clammy. The person feels terrible, and they can tell you they feel terrible. They’re tired and miserable, and they’re still themselves.

The response is what instinct suggests, done properly:

  • Stop the effort completely. Get into shade, or make some.
  • Pack off, layers loosened or shed.
  • Cool them. Wet their skin, soak a buff or shirt for the head and neck, fan them.
  • Sips of water, with electrolytes if you have them, since hours of sweating cost salt as well as fluid.

Then give it real time. Twenty minutes on a rock and straight back onto the climb is how a second, worse round starts. If they aren’t clearly improving within 30 minutes of proper rest and cooling, start arranging help. Mayo Clinic’s guidance is to contact a medical professional if symptoms get worse or don’t improve within one hour. On a trail, that means a satellite message or a call, not another hour of waiting.

Heat stroke: not themselves

Heat stroke isn’t a worse day of heat exhaustion. The cooling system has failed, core temperature keeps rising, and the brain shows it first.

The person changes. Confusion. Slurred or odd speech. Irritability or strange behavior. Stumbling that looks like more than fatigue. Not recognizing things that are obvious. They may collapse or have a seizure. The Wilderness Medical Society’s guidelines, as summarized by the AAFP, say to treat for heat stroke on suspicion, without waiting for a thermometer. The one in a trail first aid kit can’t give you a reliable core reading anyway.

The sweating myth

“They’re still sweating, so it can’t be heat stroke.” That’s wrong. Hot, dry skin is the textbook picture of classic heat stroke, the kind that hits older people during heatwaves. Exertional heat stroke, the kind that happens to hikers, runners and soldiers, often arrives with the person still soaked. The CDC’s list of heat stroke symptoms includes “hot, dry skin or profuse sweating” for exactly this reason. Don’t wait for dry skin. Watch the behavior.

Cool first, evacuate second

Call for rescue with whatever emergency communication you carry, and start cooling while it comes:

  • Shade, clothing off or soaked.
  • Cold water over as much of the body as you can, and fan them.
  • A stream or lake, if there is one and you can keep them safe in it. Whole body cold water immersion is the Wilderness Medical Society’s preferred treatment.
  • Cold packs on the neck, armpits and groin if you have them.

Cooling is the treatment, so don’t sit and wait for rescue with a full water supply untouched. A confused or semiconscious person gets cooled, not given water to drink, because they can choke on it. Fluids go to people who can hold a conversation and a bottle.

Heat exhaustion vs heat stroke, side by side

SignHeat exhaustionHeat stroke
BehaviorMiserable but still themselvesConfused, slurring, strange, stumbling
SkinOften cool, clammy, sweatingHot, and may still be sweating
What’s happeningCooling is losing groundCooling has failed
What to doStop, shade, cool, sip fluids, restCall for rescue, cool aggressively, nothing to drink if confused

Lower the odds before the climb

Start hot climbs early and rest through the worst of midday. Drink to thirst and keep water where you can reach it without stopping, which is the Wilderness Medical Society’s approach. Forcing plain water beyond thirst on a long, sweaty day carries its own risk of low blood sodium, so keep salt going in as well.

Pace so you could hold a conversation. And get some heat in your training. The same guidelines put it at about 80 percent of heat acclimatization gained in 7 days of moderate exercise in the heat for 1 to 2 hours a day, which is one more thing a summer training block builds for you. If you’re not sure your base fitness is where it should be, Am I Fit Enough for My Trek gives you the test.

If you’re trekking somewhere hot and remote, take a wilderness first aid course. Practicing these steps with an instructor is a different thing from reading them here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *